This week started out with me posting about International Women’s Day, and has me personally attending Confoo (Montreal) which is an excellent conference I hope to return to next year. I learned a lot from confoo, especially the blending nosql and sql session I attended.

This week was also the Hotsos Symposium. Doug’s Oracle Blog has a series of posts about Hotsos. If all this talk about conferences has gotten you excited, Joshua Drake notes that 14 days and the hotel is almost full for postgresql conference east which is March 25th-28th in Philadelphia. And the Oracle database insider notes that the Oracle OpenWorld call for papers is now open.

According to Susan Visser this week (ending tomorrow) is also read an e-book week. So if you have not already done so, read an e-book! She links a coupon for an e-book in the post.

Craig Mullins notes that the mainframe is a good career choice in Mainframes: The Safe IT Career Choice. He notes that the mainframe is still not dead:

People having been predicting the death of the mainframe since the advent of client/server in the late 1980s. That is more than 20 years! Think of all the things that have died in that timespan while the mainframe keeps on chugging away: IBM’s PC business, Circuit City, Koogle peanut butter, public pay phones, Johnny Cash… the list is endless.

In other career-related news, Antonio Cangiano is looking for [2] top-notch student hackers for a 16-month internship at IBM in Toronto starting in May. All the details, including how to apply, are in Cangiano’s blog post.

Willie Favero wants to know how you “solve the batch dilemma” for issues like “shrinking your batch window, designing your batch to play nicely with … OLTP” in how’s your batch workload doing? Perhaps Favero should read the updated batch best practices posted by Anthony Shorten.

Bryan Smith surveys a more personal question by asking if you go both ways and “manage both DB2 for Linux, UNIX, and Windows and DB2 for z/OS” in don’t ask, don’t tell, bi-platform DBAs. This week’s Log Buffer editor admits to being a tri-platform DBA — she has tried many platforms, and in fact, many databases (MySQL, Oracle, DB2, SQL Server, Sybase, Postgres and Ingres)!

Hari Prasanna Srinivasan promotes a patching survey in Oracle really wants to hear from you! Patching Survey.

Henrik Loeser explains what a deadlock and a hot spot are by using a real life analogy taken from a police report in deadlock and hot spot in real life.

Jamie Thomson asks why do you abbreviate schema names?. Shlomi Noach tries to solve the issue that “there is no consistent convention as for how to write [about table aliases in] an SQL query” in proper sql table alias use conventions. Noach also gives us a tip: faster than truncate.

Leons Petrazickis reminds us that “rulesets are chains” and it is important to have your rulesets in the proper order in iptables firewall pitfall.

Anyone interested in the history of MySQL AB will be informed after reading Dries Buytaert’s article.
Gavin Towey shares his software that helps centrally manage 120 MySQL servers in qsh.pl: distributed query tool For those who want to learn more about column-oriented databases, particularly in MySQL, Robin Schumacher of the InfiniDB blog announces that there is a MySQL University session recording on MySQL column databases now available. MySQL join-fu expert Jay Pipes has moved his blog to www.joinfu.com and starts with An SQL Puzzle and of course a follow up on the sql puzzle.

Ivan Zoratti is happy that finally, slides posted for the MySQL DW breakfast. Venu Anuganti gives you tips on one of the most common MySQL frustrations: optimizing subqueries in how to improve subqueries derived tables performance. Justin Swanhart posts the way in which he Gets Linux performance information from your MySQL database without shell access and emulates a ‘top’ CPU summary using /proc/stat and MySQL using the same method.

The Oracle Apps blog has an introduction to Oracle user productivity kit (UPK). Even though in this editor’s opinion the article is very sales-pitchy, it has valuable information, and does indeed live up to its promise:

UPK is a software tool that can capture all the steps in a system process. It records every keystroke, every click of the mouse, each menu option chosen and each button pressed. All this is done in the UPK Recorder by going through the transaction and pressing “printscreen” after every user action. From this, without any further effort from the developer, UPK builds a number of valuable outputs.

Allen White gives a great tip on how to optimize queries in keep your data clean.

Mike Dietrich reminds you to remove “old” parameters and events from your init.ora when upgrading, “as keeping them will definitely slow down the database performance in the new release.” He shows evidence of slowness when this is not done. Dietrich also shows how you can be gathering workload statistics “to give the optimizer some good knowledge about how powerful your IO-system might be”, especially “a few days after upgrading to the new release…while a real workload is running.”

Brian Aker shows the exciting features coming soon in Drizzle in Drizzle, Cherry, Roadmap for our Next Release.

Maybe you are thinking of migrating, not upgrading…..The O’Reilly Radar shows how to asses an Oracle to MySQL migration in MySQL migration and risk management. Actually, that article interviews Ronald Bradford on the subject — Bradford has been prolific lately, updating free my.cnf advice series and “Don’t Assume”: MySQL for the Oracle DBA series. Nick Quarmby also talks about migrating Oracle, but not to a new database, just to a new platform, in his primer on migrating Oracle Applications to new platforms. And the big news comes from Carlos of dataprix that Twitter will migrate from MySQL to Cassandra DB.

Paul S. Randal explains his way of benchmarking: 1 Tb table population on SQL Server.

Pete Finnigan shares his slides from a webinar on how to secure oracle, and Denis Pilipchuk shares his approaches for discovering security vulnerabilities in software applications.

Jeff Davis shares his thoughts about scalability and the relational model. Robert Treat responds actually, the relational model doesn’t scale and Baron Schwartz counters with NoSQL doesn’t mean non-relational.

Buck Woody explains “whenever you want to know something about SQL Server’s configuration, whether that’s the Instance itself or a database, you have a few options” — and of course what those options are — in system variables, stored procedures or functions for meta data.

This week’s T-SQL Tuesday topic was I/O. There are many links to great blog posts in the comments; three random posts I chose to highlight: Michael Zilberstein talks about IO capacity planning, while Kalen Delaney talks about using STATISTICS IO in I/O, you know, and Merrill Aldrich chimes in with information on real world SSD’s. Aldrich also begs folks not to waste resources and make more work for developers and DBAs in dear ISV, you’re keeping me awake nights with your VARCHAR() dates.

And we end with a bit of fin: Paul Nielsen wants us all to have a bit of fun; he has posted an SQL limerick and asks readers to create there own in there once was in Dublin a query.

I arrived at Omni Mandalay Hotel on Sunday evening with Dan Norris. I was flying through Chicago and it turned out that Dan was on the same flight and only few rows behind me. Small world.

Preparations for the conference were very chaotic on my part and, of course, I didn’t have either of my presentations ready. I was very stressed and getting sick as well — it looked like a complete disaster waiting to happen. I’d like to say that I was feeling like Doug Burns as he often managed to get sick just before a conference. Of course, I worked on my slides for the last few days as well as on the flight and presentation was slowly getting there but boy was I tired!

I quickly said hello to the crowd in the bar on the way to my room and rushed away to do some more damage to my slides. And then I had a brilliant idea — I could still see one of my best mates and do something good about my presentation! I asked Doug if he was interested in the preview (he probably wasn’t interested but he couldn’t say it to me) especially that my session wasn’t on his original agenda. Of course, that would mean that he had to leave a bunch of other good friends and spend some time tete-a-tete. Knowing Doug, this is some of the hardest thing to ask from him but it shows how good of a friend he is! (Plus, everyone thinks that he is anti-social anyway. Shhhh!)

Doug has made my day — while he provided lots of ideas and feedback on few things that I was lucking, he generally approved the idea and confirmed that it wasn’t totally crazy. I guess that was all I needed back then and Doug knew how nervous I was about it. (Thanks mate!)

So I called Sunday a day very early and went to bed before midnight. I really needed some sleep. Woken up by the alarm at 5AM (I woke up few times during the night looking at the clock — making sure I didn’t sleep through) and slides were ready just before lunch. I even managed to do a test run and it took 65 minutes — a wee bit too long for one hour session. But it was good test and I knew I had to be just a bit more concise in few parts.

Mi morning was very productive. Unfortunately, I missed the opening keynote from Tom Kyte. Such a pity! If what Doug wrote is true, Tom was talking about the mistakes we make *because* of our experience and our assumptions. This was exactly one of the points I was making in my Battle Against Any Guess — experience is danger. I wish I could see Tom’s example. Oh well, maybe another time.

I managed to attend half of the Richard Foote’s session on indexes but my mind was far away — with my own slides. Though, I did manage to focus on bitmap indexes part and the myth of bitmap indexes not working well for columns with high cardinality. Very interesting conclusions. I’m still wondering how much overhead updates will do to such bitmap index.

After lunch, it was my turn. I ordered few copies of the latest OakTable book — Expert Oracle Practices: Oracle Database Administration from the Oak Table — that I co-authored with the bunch of other Oakies. I contributed chapter 1 in the book titled just like my presentation — Battle Against Any Guess. The plan was to give a copy away during the presentation and do a draw for another one at the end of the session. I was so nervous that I forgot about it until the end of the session so I just did a draw for two copies. The lucky winners were Lynn-Georgia Tesch and Surendra Anchula. Congratulations! For the rest of you who left the contact details — please stay tuned and we’ll organize few things online.

Now the main topic of this post — my presentation. What’s unusual about this session is that it’s not some technical stuff that I usually do but a more conceptual and motivational talk. Could I pull it off? Well, I think it went fairly well in general even though I did identify few rough places and my lack of English language mastering. Might need to work a little bit more on the flow of the presentation.

We had quite a few good laughs. Later, people in the next hall were asking about it and Dan was making the jokes on the stage so it must have been loud. Anyway, I think nobody fell asleep and I managed to get people thinking about the topic. I received many “thank you” notes yesterday and compliments on a good session so by the end of the day I was more and more pleased. Thanks everyone for attending and especially big thanks to those of you who brought to my attention examples from their own battles. If you have more to discuss — contact me by email (my last name) {at} pythian.com.

Thanks to Marco Gralike for recording some fragments and sharing them. I think he has more to come.

This is the introductory couple minutes. You can definitely notice how nervous I am starting on the stage:

Solving the wrong problem example:

That’s all for now. Stay tuned — more to come.

Start planning your blog posts for Ada Lovelace day now (March 24th, http://findingada.com/ Ada Lovelace Day is an international day of blogging (videologging, podcasting, comic drawing etc.!) to draw attention to the achievements of women in technology and science.)

To that end, I would like to point out all the women currently in science and tech fields that I admire and think are doing great things. I think it would be great if everyone, male or female, made a list like this:

The women that have taught me science/tech along the way:

High School:
Mary Lou Ciavarra (Physics)
Maria Petretti (Pre-Algebra, and Academic Decathlon)
Reneé Fishman (Biology)
Lisa Acquaire (Economics during Academic Decathlon)

College:
Professor Kalpana White (Biology), and in whose fruit fly lab I worked for 2 semesters.
Professor Eve Marder (Introductory Neuroscience)

Though Brandeis does have female faculty in the Computer Science department, I did not manage to have any classes with female Computer Science faculty members.

My current female DBA co-workers at Pythian: Isabel Pinarci (Oracle), Michelle Gutzait (SQL Server), Catherine Chow (Oracle) and Jasmine Wen (Oracle).

And to folks in the greater MySQL/tech community and tech co-workers past and present, especially those I have been inspired and helped by: Tracy Gangwer, Selena Deckelmann (Postgres), Amy Rich, Anne Cross, and more (If I have forgotten you, I apologize!).

Having recently moved his blog, Gary approached the Log Buffer coordinator to volunteer for an edition because he knows that, with LB being a popular and established destination in the database blogoshphere, it would help him broadcast his new blog and welcome readers to it. You can do it too–simply send an email to the Log Buffer coordinator.

Here’s Gary’s Log Buffer #181.

This is something that, at Pythian, we internalized a long time ago when thinking about MySQL tuning. In fact, mysqltuner 2.0 takes this into account, and the default configuration includes looking at both ratios and rates.

If I told you that your database had a ratio of temporary tables written to disk of 20%, you might think “aha, my database is slow because of a lot of file I/O caused by writing temporary tables to disk!”. However, that 20% ratio may actually mean a rate of 2 per hour — which is most likely not causing excessive I/O.

To get a sense of this concept, and also how mysqltuner works, I will show the lines from the mysqltuner default configuration that deal with temporary tables written to disk. The format is that the fields are separated by three pipes (|||), and the fields are:

label
threshold check
formula
recommendation if “threshold check” is met

Here is the line from the default configuration file that calculates the rate of temporary tables written to disk:

% temp disk tables|||>25|||Created_tmp_disk_tables / (Created_tmp_tables + Created_tmp_disk_tables) * 100|||Too many temporary tables are being written to disk.  Increase max_heap_table_size and tmp_table_size.

mysqltuner will parse that as:

if
the value of Created_tmp_disk_tables/(Created_tmp_tables + Created_tmp_disk_tables)*100
>25
then print out the last field.

So that means that a ratio of 25% or more is the threshold. But we found that many clients have a ratio much less than 25%, but still had excessive temporary tables written to disk. So the default configuration also contains a rate calculation of temporary tables written to disk:

temp disk rate|||=~ /second|minute/|||&hr_bytime(Created_tmp_disk_tables/Uptime)|||Too many temporary tables are being written to disk.  Increase max_heap_table_size and tmp_table_size.

mysqltuner will parse that as:

if
the value of &hr_bytime(Created_tmp_disk_tables/Uptime)
matches “second” or “minute”
then print out the last field.

The hr_bytime() function in mysqltuner takes a number that is a per-second rate and makes it “human readable” (hence “hr”) by returning the order of magnitude at which the value is >1. For example:

hr_bytime(2) returns “2.0 per second”
hr_bytime(0.2) returns “12.0 per minute”
hr_bytime(0.02) returns “1.2 per minute”
hr_bytime(0.002) returns “7.2 per hour”
hr_bytime(0.0002) returns “17.28 per day”

Certainly, 0.02 looks small, but “12 per minute” is a better metric for a DBA to understand the problem.

Because the configuration file for mysqltuner 2.0 contains the threshold and check, it is fairly simple to change what the threshold is, and to check both rates and ratios. mysqltuner also allows you to output in different formats (currently there’s “pretty” and “csv”, but it’s easy to add a perl subroutine to do something different with the output), which makes it ideal for doing regular tuning checks for what is most important for you.

Pythian uses it on one client to provide weekly reports, which we add to a spreadsheet so that differences are easy to see. (yes, output directly to a database is on the “features we want to add” — mysqltuner is just a perl script, so if anyone in the community wants to add it, they can create a branch and request the feature to be added into the main trunk…it is all on launchpad, at https://launchpad.net/mysqltuner, so community contributions are recommended and encouraged.)

Welcome to the MySQL monitor.  Commands end with ; or \g.
Your MySQL connection id is 15
Server version: 5.1.41-log MySQL Community Server (GPL)

Type 'help;' or '\h' for help. Type '\c' to clear the buffer.

mysql> grant alter,create,insert on *.* to 'test'@localhost;
Query OK, 0 rows affected (0.00 sec)

mysql> show warnings;
Empty set (0.00 sec)

mysql> show errors;
Empty set (0.00 sec)

mysql>

The reason I granted the addition CREATE and INSERT privileges is that according to the MySQL documentation (http://dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/5.1/en/privileges-provided.html), they are required by the ALTER privilege:

The ALTER privilege enables use of ALTER TABLE to change the structure of or rename tables. (ALTER TABLE also requires the INSERT and CREATE privileges.)

The user was attempting to rename a table with the ALTER TABLE [NAME] RENAME [NAME2] command and seeing the following error:

mysql> alter table test1 rename test2;
ERROR 1142 (42000): DROP command denied to user 'test'@'localhost' for table 'test1'

mysql> show grants;
+----------------------------------------------------------+
| Grants for test@localhost                                |
+----------------------------------------------------------+
| GRANT INSERT, CREATE, ALTER ON *.* TO 'test'@'localhost' |
+----------------------------------------------------------+
1 row in set (0.00 sec)

mysql> show tables;
+----------------+
| Tables_in_test |
+----------------+
| test1          |
+----------------+
1 row in set (0.00 sec)

Of course I immediately realized what the issue was. In MySQL, ALTER TABLE [NAME] RENAME [NEW_NAME] is done as a DROP (which requires the DROP privilege and CREATE TABLE (which requires the CREATE privilege). So I granted the user the DROP privilege. This time the user was able to successful rename the table as shown below:

mysql> show tables;
+----------------+
| Tables_in_test |
+----------------+
| test1          |
+----------------+
1 row in set (0.00 sec)

mysql> alter table test1 rename test2;
Query OK, 0 rows affected (0.00 sec)

mysql> show grants;
+----------------------------------------------------------------+
| Grants for test@localhost                                      |
+----------------------------------------------------------------+
| GRANT INSERT, CREATE, DROP, ALTER ON *.* TO 'test'@'localhost' |
+----------------------------------------------------------------+
1 row in set (0.00 sec)

mysql> show tables;
+----------------+
| Tables_in_test |
+----------------+
| test2          |
+----------------+
1 row in set (0.00 sec)

The MySQL documentation on the ALTER privilege states that it only need CREATE and INSERT but makes no mention of the requirement for DROP privilege. The RENAME TABLE documentation at http://dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/5.1/en/rename-table.html does mention:

When you execute RENAME, you cannot have any locked tables or active transactions. You must also have the ALTER and DROP privileges on the original table, and the CREATE and INSERT privileges on the new table.

However, that should be explicit in the ALTER TABLE documentation, because if you use ALTER TABLE...RENAME you will not necessarily read the documentation for the RENAME TABLE syntax.

To make the documentation better for everyone, I have filed a MySQL Bug Report on this documentation – Bug 51593.

Oracle

There was so much Oracle stuff this week that I’ve decided to cram a little more of it into Log Buffer by providing a little less context than usual.

Jonathan Lewis shares an explication of aliases: “I was asked the following question recently: ‘Does the use of table aliases affect performance?’ To which the best answer is probably ‘Yes, though in general you probably won’t notice the difference and there are reasons more imporant [sic] than performance for using table aliases.’”

Doug Burns continues his most recent series: Statistics on Partitioned Tables – Part 2, and Statistics on Partitioned Tables – Part 3.

Charles Schultz demonstrates how VPD + bad ANYDATA practices can really bite: “The point of my blog was that using CAST can really screw up your data. Oracle Support is filing a bug on this behavior, as it looks like an overflow problem.”

Pythian’s Gleb Otochkin begins a series on Oracle GoldenGate installation.

Guy Harrison provides a thorough introduction and recommendations on memory management for Oracle databases on VMWare ESX.

Robert Vollman returns to blogging and offers his 10-point plan on improving your SQL queries.

Jared Still sheds some light on a cool but unknown RMAN feature.

Richard Foote knocks holes in another myth: “One of the great myths in Oracle is that bitmap indexes are only suitable and should only be used with columns that have so-called low cardinality (few distinct) values.”

Alexander Kornbrust shares a link to a really good whitepaper about “Hacking Oracle from the Web” by Sumit Siddarth.

Eddie Awad shares a link to a SQL injection prevention cheat sheet.

Charles Hooper answers the question, What is the meaning of the %CPU column in an explain plan?.

Meanwhile, Harald van Breederode does the same for this one: Why does the size of my ORACLE_HOME increase?

SQL Server

Thomas LaRock gives an recap of MS’s 2010 MVP Summit. Quotable take-away: “If I had to compare SQL 2008 R2 to SQL Server 4.0, I would say the difference is the same as comparing an F1 race car to a Chevy Vega.”

Half a world away, there is the SQLSocial Event – London March 16th, as advertised by Simon Sabin.

Simon also shares a script to get indexes and their included columns, beginning, “I get increasingly frustrated with the lack of visibility of included columns in management studio and from the system stored procedures sp_… This is a query that returns all indexes and there key and include columns[.]”

Andy Leonard throws us another nourishing SSIS snack: conditional split outputs.

Here’s Rob Farley with a book review of an oldie but a goodie: Inside SQL 2005 Query Tuning and Optimization, by Kalen Delaney et al. “If you spend any time tuning SQL Server databases, then this book will feel much thicker than it really is, and you’ll be finding useful information on just about every page.”

Thomas LaRock, meanwhile, writes that SQL Server 2008 Query Performance Tuning Distilled is
a good way to start your day. “Each morning, while I wait for my desktop to boot, I pick up their book, turn to any page, and just start reading.”

MySQL

Sticking with the theme a little longer, here is Baron Schwartz with a review of Understanding MySQL Internals by Sasha Pachev. “I should have read this book a long time ago, and it’s my loss that I didn’t.  . . .  Overall, this book is easily a high 4 stars on a scale of 5, and again, anyone seriously using MySQL should have it.”

Baron also shares a link to Oracle guy Cary Millsap’s Thinking Clearly about Performance paper.

Brian “Krow” Aker starts an extensive conversation with his post, Protocols, The GPL, Influences from MySQL. His thesis, “MySQL was the company that had the most influence on how companies and investors viewed the GPL.”

Paul Vallée of Pythian responds with his ideas on product management, effective developers, and the future of MySQL. “ . . . the future of MySQL, Drizzle, Monty Program, the Percona fork, etc.” to be more precise.

Colin Charles provides news of what’s been happening recently in MariaDB #1.

Mohammad Lahlouh wonders, can I use latin1 to store utf8 data? and gets several answers from his readers.

He might have asked Ronald Bradford, who knows this stuff. Here is his post on migrating MySQL latin1 to utf8 – character set options.

Pursuing a similar matter (collations), Roland Bouman opines, the best stored routine is the one you don’t write.

PostgreSQL

Baron Schwartz again! He announces, mk-query-digest now supports Postgres logs.

David Fetter says, part(ition)ing is such sweet sorrow. “There are excellent references on partitioning tables that depend on one table, but what happens when you need to partition the referenced table? Let’s find out!”

Bruce Momjian is here with news on the Python driver confusion.

Jon Jensen of End Point’s Blog posts a HOWTO on PostgreSQL EC2/EBS/RAID 0 snapshot backup.

NoSQL, Etc.

Chen Shapira has been at the compass and protractor, mapping the NoSQL space and returns from terra incognita unscathed.

Ronald Bradford has been getting started with Cassandra, one of the outposts on Chen’s map, and shares his steps.

Arnie Rowland says, “Mark your calendar! Portland SQLSaturday/CodeCamp/Barcamp 2010 is scheduled for May 22, 2010, at the University of Portland campus.  . . .  Portland SQLSaturday is encouraging presentations related to interoperability of any of the SQL platforms, including T-SQL (SQL Server), PostgreSQL, MySQL, and PL-SQL. Abstracts for Platform specific sessions are also encouraged.”

Okay, that is all for this edition. You guys are running me ragged! Fortunately, Gary Myers picks it up next week on his Sydney Oracle Lab. Till then!

$> mysqlbinlog mysql-bin.000003 > 03.sql
$> mysql < 03.sql

Turning off binary logging for a session is not difficult, from the MySQL commandline, if you authenticate as a user with the SUPER privilege:

mysql> SET SESSION sql_log_bin=0;

However, sometimes you want to apply binary logs to a MySQL instance, without having those changes applied to the binary logs themselves. One option is to restart the server binary logging disabled, and after the load is finished, restart the server with binary logging re-enabled. This is not always possible nor desirable, so there’s a better way, that works in at least versions 4.1 and up:

The mysqlbinlog utility has the --disable-log-bin option. All the option does is add the SET SESSION sql_log_bin=0; statement to the beginning of the output, but it is certainly much better than restarting the server twice!

Here’s the manual page for the --disable-log-bin option of mysqlbinlog: http://dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/5.1/en/mysqlbinlog.html#option_mysqlbinlog_disable-log-bin


MySQL is now just a branch (the official branch,
but a branch nonetheless, and a bunch of trademark (logo) and
copyright (docs) ownerships).


This is exactly true. No denying it. Why bother. It’s true. It’s also true for the vast majority of open-source projects, by the way.

I replied to Sheeri:


There's no denying that. The product direction will be set by whoever sets the best product management strategy backed by the most effective development effort. And there can be multiple winners.
-Paul


Well, this is the kind of quality output I can be relied on. It might not fit on twitter, but it’s not blogworthy. Sheeri’s word of encouragement:


See, now that would be a nice blog post with a positive outlook that
both Oracle Corp and MySQL community would agree and be happy with,
because both Oracle Corp and the MySQL community feel they can set
"the best product management strategy backed by the most effective
development effort."
-Sheeri


God. My reply was embarassing but maybe I should include it for humour value:


Go for it. Its a tweet for me at the most. No time to expand that thinking into a blog worthy of the blog today.
-Paul


and then, right away,


ah censored it i'll do it.
it'll be short.
-paul


You are now reading the result of this very modest effort.

Here’s the future of MySQL, Drizzle, Monty Program, the Percona fork, etc.

The best product management strategies… should we be lightweight for the web, plug-in oriented like Drizzle? Should we follow Monty’s giant-killing roadmap? Should we focus on performance-oriented patches? The best product management strategies will win.

They can’t win alone. Will they be backed by appropriate investments from effective developers? Effective developers are the ones who convert winning product management strategies into working products. You can’t get there without them and I’ve seen lots of great strategies fail that test (including my own actually).

And there can be more than one winner.

It’s doesn’t matter what roadmap Oracle plots for MySQL. If it’s not the roadmap the community wants, it will lose ground and open an opportunity for another fork. If it is, however, (and NEVER, NEVER underestimate Oracle’s product management because it is outstanding and a big component of their historical success), if it is, however, Oracle can win the long-term hearts and minds, because they can resource quality developers in a way that I don’t think any of the competing forks are capitalized to do (yet.)

Either way, it’s going to be fun to watch.

And more than one player can win.

And regardless, the community wins. Big time.

I was sad that last year there was no community dinner, and I missed the one the year before when Jonathan Schwartz and Rich Green made an appearance. This year I am determined not to miss it, and so I am calling for a community (pay-your-own-way) dinner on Monday, April 12th, at Pedro’s – a Mexican restaurant that has vegetarian and vegan options. I think Monday is a better time because many folks arrive Sunday evening, or even Monday morning (there are tutorials on Monday, but not everyone attends).

Pedro’s can handle large groups of people, but we would like to have a vague idea of how many people are attending — while you are not required to RSVP, we would like to make an accurate reservation at Pedro’s….In 2008, there was a wiki page with a list of attendees, and I was disappointed because there were so many people on that list I wanted to see.

Meet us at 6:30 pm on Monday in the lobby of the Hyatt Santa Clara, or at 7 pm at Pedro’s. If you want to come later, just show up at Pedro’s whenever you can.

Since commenting on this blog does not require registration (as the wiki does), I invite folks to comment on this blog post and I’ll add you to the list of attendees:

1. Sheeri K. Cabral (The Pythian Group)
2. Paul Vallee (The Pythian Group)
3. Rob Hamel (The Pythian Group)
4. Giuseppe Maxia (Sun)
5. Brian Aker (Drizzle)
6. Konstantin Osipov (Sun)
7. Mark Callaghan (Facebook) (will arrive later)
8. Wagner Bianchi (EAC Software, Brazil)
9. Roland Bouman (BI wizard)
10. Bill Karwin (Karwin Software Solutions)
11. Maxim Volkov (OpenCandy)
12. Brian Moon (DealNews) – note: Monday Apr 12th is Brian’s birthday!
13. Rob Peck (DealNews)
14. Arjen Lentz (OpenQuery)
15. Vadim Tkachenko (Percona)
16. Rohit Nadhani (WebYog)
17. Paul McCullagh (PrimeBase)
18. Monty Widenius (Monty Program)
19. Sergei Golubchik (Monty Program)
20. Kristian Nielsen (Monty Program)
21. Henrik Ingo (Monty Program)
22. Nick Westerlund (Tuenti)
23. Sergey Petrunya (Monty Program)
24. Eric Day (Rackspace (Drizzle))
25. Lenz Grimmer (Sun Microsystems)
26. Garry Hamilton-Smith (Gazal)
27. John Russell (IBM?)
28. Bryan Alsdorf (Monty Program)
29. Baron Schwartz (Percona) (Tentative yes)
30. Mark Atwood (Gear6)
31. Gillian Gunson (?)
32. Robin Johnson (Gentoo, phpMyAdmin)
33. Ivan Zoratti (MySQL)
34. Henrique Sidney (MySQL)
35. Tom Disheroon (Sun Microsystems)
36. Chris Schneider (Ning.com)
37. Kevin Knapp (Facebook)
38. Daniel Bartholomew (Monty Program)
39. Luca Olivari (Sun Microsystems)