Why your current database managed service RFP process fails

The request for proposal (RFP) process for database managed services often feels like a checklist exercise to find a low-cost provider with 24/7 coverage. 

However, the true goal is to find a strategic partner, not just a vendor. When you choose a partner based on price alone, you often get reactive support and siloed teams. This leads to system failures and the need to run another costly search just a few years later.

This process is high stakes. You are securing the operations of your business for the next several years. If your database managed service provider RFP focuses only on cost, you risk partnering with a firm that only fixes things when they break.

This checklist provides the experience-driven questions you must ask to find a partner that acts as an extension of your team.

The three pillars of a successful database managed service RFP

We evaluate the best database managed service proposals on three core pillars beyond price. Ensure your scoring matrix emphasizes these points to select a reliable, long-term partner.

• The right database managed service for your active RFPs has breadth and depth of expertise across multi-platforms. Does the provider specialize in your entire technology stack, from legacy systems to cloud-native databases? A narrow focus leads to vendor sprawl. Pythian experts cover more than 45 database and cloud technologies. This allows you to consolidate vendors and simplify management—a decisive factor in winning technical RFPs.
• The right database managed service has a proactive service delivery model, this is non-negotiable to determine when fulfilling your MSP RFP. Is the service reactive (fixing things when they break) or proactive (optimization and prevention)? Pythian delivers proactive database support. Our teams of database consultants and database administrators (DBAs) continuously optimize performance. We ensure your data is available and scales with demand. Additionally, our proprietary monitoring tools provide continuous health checks and alerts so we see issues before they happen. 
• Adaptability and partnership, think beyond the database managed service RFP contract. Can the vendor integrate as an extension of your team with flexible contracts? Pythian designs engagement models for flexibility.

Our consistent success in competitive processes proves we hit the high bar across all three pillars. As one customer’s Director of Digital Technology and Operations shared: "Whenever we would get into discussions or debates about the various vendors in the RFP process, Pythian was always the high bar. They’ve proven that they can give us the service we need."

Checklist: 15 questions to evaluate your database managed service provider

Pillar 1: Technical depth and multi-platform expertise

Technical capability must extend beyond simple knowledge. Your provider needs specialized proficiency across your entire data ecosystem.

Question 1: Do you have evidence of managing our exact database stack in hybrid or multi-cloud environments?

Look for quantifiable experience. A strong provider must support your entire legacy and cloud-native portfolio (market leaders often cover 45 or more technologies). This prevents vendor sprawl and ensures expertise in complex migrations.

Question 2: How do you guarantee senior DBA expertise in your 24/7 model, and what percent of your team holds senior certification?

Do not settle for junior staff handling critical operations. The best responses will detail a clear escalation path. They will show that only highly certified specialists handle major incidents, even overnight.

Question 3: How do you support databases across multi-cloud (AWS, Azure, GCP) and on-premise infrastructure?

In today's fragmented data landscape, your selected provider must demonstrate expertise in managing databases regardless of where they reside, ensuring unified monitoring and support across all environments.

Pillar 2: Operational model, proactivity, and guaranteed service

A great RFP response outlines a proactive model focused on prevention. Ask vendors to detail their operational mechanics.

Question 4: What proprietary monitoring tools do you use, and can our team access the dashboard 24/7?

Proprietary tools built on decades of operational knowledge often outperform off-the-shelf software. Vendor lock-in risk is acceptable if the tools provide continuous health checks and real-time visibility that your team can access.

Question 5: What are your guaranteed response and resolution times (SLAs) for P1 and P2 incidents?

The best database managed service providers offer aggressive service level agreements (SLAs). They commit to engaging high-level specialists almost immediately for critical issues. Rapid response is paramount; look for maximum resolution commitments.

Question 6: How do you handle proactive management versus reactive support?

If the vendor does not emphasize performance optimization and preventative maintenance, you are buying a reactive service. A partner should reduce operational risk and enable performance gains. For example, the streaming platform SoundCloud achieved an 84 percent speed increase with their selected partner.

Question 7: Do you have a documented, week-by-week onboarding plan to guarantee a smooth transition?

The transition to a new managed service provider (MSP) must be transparent and rapid. Look for a detailed plan that covers asset assessment, readiness review, documentation, and a communication plan. This is essential for high-compliance environments. 

Pillar 3: Partnership, value alignment, and future security

Your chosen partner must provide flexible terms, stability, and a commitment to compliance.

Question 8: Can you show a successful multi-year engagement with a customer in a regulated industry?

A long-term relationship signals stability and trust. Look for case studies that validate success in environments with strict compliance and security needs, such as financial services or healthcare.

Question 9: What is your annualized Net Promoter Score (NPS)?

High customer satisfaction is non-negotiable. An NPS in the 90s—like Pythian’s 94 percent score—indicates reliable service. This should be a key metric in your final score.

Question 10: What flexible contract models do you offer?

Rigid contracts are a red flag. A high-value partner offers flexible models that adapt as your business evolves. You should only pay for the management you need.

Question 11: What security certifications do you hold, and how do you secure client access?

Security compliance is critical. Demand proof of certifications (like ISO or SOC). Ask for a clear explanation of how the vendor manages, audits, and protects administrative access according to strict standards.

Question 12: What strategic consulting services do you offer beyond operational support?

A true partner views your database as a business enabler, not just a system to patch. Look for vendors who help you use your data platform for next-generation initiatives. This includes cost optimization (FinOps), advanced analytics, or machine learning.

Question 13: How do you automate reporting, and what level of review do we receive?

Ensure the vendor analyzes performance metrics rather than just delivering them. A strategic provider offers regular executive reviews. They translate operational data into business recommendations for cost efficiencies and scaling.

Question 14: Describe your disaster recovery and business continuity strategy.

Operational resilience is paramount. Your vendor must demonstrate expertise in high-availability solutions. They must have documented processes for testing failover scenarios to minimize recovery time objectives (RTO) and recovery point objectives (RPO). 

Question 15: What cost optimization guarantees do you include in your contract?

Cost savings should result from technical efficiency, such as rightsizing cloud resources, rather than cutting support corners. Seek partners who use FinOps best practices to continuously reduce cloud database spend.

If you are drafting an RFP for a database managed service provider, or replacing an underperforming vendor, demand the high bar. Use the expertise of a partner with deep technical skills and a flexible service model.

Get started with Pythian's database managed services

Ready for better database management—for less?